POINT BLANCHE PRISONERS RIGHTS SUSPENDED DUTCH ST MAARTEN SXM! IS THIS LEGAL?
https://www.facebook.com/share/1BhNEK8rjG
On May 18, 2025, the Director of Pointe Blanche Prison in Sint Maarten, Mr. S. Carty, enacted a temporary suspension of specific inmate rights and privileges.
This decisive action followed a significant riot and subsequent fire on May 14, which inflicted substantial damage on the prison’s infrastructure and disrupted its operations. The suspension, grounded in Articles 31 and 32 of the Prison Regulation (Gevangenismaatregel), aims to restore safety and order within the facility.
Legal Framework for Suspension
Article 31 of the Prison Regulation permits the prison director to deviate from established detainee rights when necessary to maintain institutional safety or order. Article 32 extends this authority, allowing for the suspension or restriction of rights for all individuals within the institution for up to three consecutive 24-hour periods in cases of widespread or serious incidents. Should the emergency persist beyond this initial 72-hour window, only the Minister of Justice holds the authority to extend the suspension in additional 72-hour increments.
Scope of the Suspension
The suspension encompasses all detainee rights and privileges related to visitation, recreation, group activities, and external communications, except where essential to legal proceedings. This measure applies uniformly to all detainees, irrespective of their classification or location within the facility. The decision is not disciplinary but a precautionary and operational measure aimed at stabilizing the situation and facilitating the safe recovery of essential services and infrastructure.
Underlying Issues at Pointe Blanche Prison
The recent unrest is symptomatic of longstanding systemic issues within Pointe Blanche Prison. Reports have highlighted chronic staff shortages, inadequate medical care, and deteriorating infrastructure. In April 2025, prisoners initiated a strike over the quality of food and lack of medical attention, with reports of spoiled meals and insufficient healthcare services. Staff absenteeism has further exacerbated these problems, leading to delayed meal times and restricted access to medical care. The prison has also faced challenges with maintaining basic amenities, such as functional washing machines, and addressing insect infestations. These conditions have raised serious concerns about the well-being of both inmates and staff.
Calls for Comprehensive Reform
The Law Enforcement Council has repeatedly emphasized the urgent need for structural reforms at Pointe Blanche Prison. In 2018, the Council reported that the prison’s conditions had deteriorated beyond acceptable standards, citing inadequate facilities, insufficient staff training, and a lack of resocialization programs. The Council stressed that the prison was ill-prepared to prevent and manage emergencies, posing unjustified risks to society. It called for decisive action from the Ministry of Justice and other stakeholders to implement structural measures and improve the prison’s overall functioning.
Recent Incidents Highlighting Security Concerns
Security lapses have further underscored the need for reform. In May 2024, an inmate in an isolation cell was attacked by two masked individuals dressed in prison uniforms. The assailants accessed the isolation area through multiple doors that should have been secured, raising suspicions of internal corruption. Minister of Justice Lyndon Lewis acknowledged the severity of the incident and initiated an investigation to address potential corruption within the prison system.
Efforts Toward Improvement
In response to these challenges, the prison administration has taken steps to address some of the issues. A training program for prison officers was initiated in September 2022, in collaboration with the Dutch Custodial Agency, to enhance staff skills in areas such as integrity, self-defense, and prison law. Additionally, plans are underway to upgrade the inmate telephone system to a VOIP-based system, aiming to improve communication between inmates and their families.
Conclusion
The temporary suspension of inmate rights and privileges at Pointe Blanche Prison is a critical measure to restore order following the recent riot and fire. However, it also highlights the pressing need for comprehensive reforms to address the systemic issues plaguing the facility. Ensuring the safety and well-being of both inmates and staff requires a concerted effort from the prison administration, the Ministry of Justice, and other stakeholders to implement lasting solutions.